Michigan Pauses Pass/Fail Grading Plan: What It Means for Academically-Struggling Students
The University of Michigan wanted to take some pressure off freshmen during their first semester. The idea? Let students adjust to college without worrying that every grade could hurt their GPA.
For now, that plan is on hold.
Why Michigan’s Pass/Fail Grading Plan Was Paused
The proposed pilot would have allowed first-semester students in the College of Literature, Science, and the Arts to receive letter grades while showing only “pass” or “no credit” on their transcripts, which would not count towards their GPAs.
University leaders hoped the change would cut down on stress, encourage students to explore new subjects, and help them settle into college life. Not everyone was convinced. Critics worry that students might put less effort into coursework if their letter grades weren’t put on a transcript.
In September 2026, university President Domenico Grasso paused the proposal, calling for a more thorough review of the policy. He also expressed concern that the national backlash was creating an unfair impression of Michigan students.
The debate raises a bigger question: How much can grading policies affect a student’s future?
If your grades are threatening your enrollment, hire the LLF National Law Firm to help protect your educational opportunities. Our LLF National Law Firm Education Law Team represents students nationwide facing possible dismissal from college or university.
Call us at 888-535-3686, or send us a message online and tell us about your case.
When One Bad Grade Puts Your Education at Risk
A disappointing grade can be frustrating. But sometimes, it’s more than that.
Colleges and universities have satisfactory academic progress requirements that students must meet to remain eligible for financial aid. These generally include:
- Maintaining a minimum GPA
- Completing enough credits
- Making progress toward graduation within an established timeframe
Fall short, and you could face ineligibility for financial aid. The university also has academic standards you must meet. Fall short on those standards, and you could face academic probation. Continued problems may lead to dismissal. One failing grade could push your GPA below the school’s minimum, even if you’ve done well in your other classes.
When Can Students Challenge a Grade?
Students facing academic dismissal shouldn’t assume the school’s decision is beyond challenge.
Mistakes happen. For example, a professor might calculate a grade incorrectly. An administrator could overlook completed coursework or apply an academic progress policy inconsistently. Sometimes, important circumstances may not be properly considered.
And what about the grade itself?
Many colleges allow students to appeal grades when there’s evidence of a calculation error, inconsistent grading standards, or failure to follow established procedures. Disagreeing with a professor isn’t enough, but a legitimate grading error may provide grounds for an appeal.
Correcting that grade could make the difference between staying enrolled and facing dismissal.
Facing Academic Dismissal? We Can Help.
A low GPA doesn’t always have to end your education.
Our LLF National Law Firm Education Law Team can review your academic record, examine school policies, challenge errors, and negotiate with administrators to help you stay enrolled. When necessary, we’ll pursue further action to protect your interests.
If you’re facing probation or dismissal for failing to make academic progress, don’t wait until your options narrow.
Hire the LLF National Law Firm to fight for your education. Call us at 888-535-3686 or send us a message online and tell us about your case.