Since its release in November 2022, ChatGPT has revolutionized the way people write – and the way writing is scrutinized. A recent incident at Texas A&M University–Commerce reveals the growing pains associated with AI use in education. A professor at the school flunked an entire class based on false claims of plagiarism. The case raises important questions about the ethical implications of AI misuse and underscores the importance of finding appropriate safeguards to protect academic integrity.

The Misguided Professor

The Texas A&M University-Commerce professor's decision to use ChatGPT to detect plagiarism in his students' final assignments was fundamentally flawed. ChatGPT is a chatbot, not a plagiarism detector. This led to a complete misjudgment of student work, jeopardizing their academic reputations. It's important that professors thoroughly understand the tools they use – and their limitations. AI plagiarism detection tools can come in handy for tasks like this. ChatGPT, however, should not be used to assess student work.

The impact of plagiarism accusations on students can be significant. Accusing an entire class of plagiarism and temporarily withholding their diplomas is an egregious violation of their rights. Students deserve the opportunity to address concerns of academic dishonesty. While some have been able to exonerate themselves, others remain under investigation.

Inadequate Response from the University

Students say they are frustrated by the lack of an immediate response from the university administration on the issue. Prompt, effective communication is essential in such situations. Students deserve their concerns to be addressed swiftly. The delayed response may further strain the relationship between the school and students. With the faith of their student body on the line, the school must take action and rectify this situation as soon as possible.

At the very least, Texas A&M University–Commerce must create clear guidelines and policies surrounding AI tools. ChatGPT is here to stay, and it's up to universities and colleges to properly train faculty to understand both the capabilities and the limitations of AI tools. Institutions must invest in AI plagiarism detection systems designed with academic work in mind. These measures can help prevent AI misuse while protecting students from unwarranted accusations.

The Implications for Higher Education

Some schools in the United States have blocked ChatGPT from campus use altogether. This strategy is a Band-Aid fix for a problem that will only continue to grow more complicated as AI advances. This incident at Texas A&M University–Commerce should be a wake-up call for schools worldwide. Universities must take a proactive approach to developing policies that balance the benefits of AI with the safeguarding of educational integrity.

In part two of our blog series on AI in modern education, we'll dive into more of the implications that ChatGPT has on colleges and universities. In the meantime, if you're uncertain where your school stands on AI use, or you've been accused of misusing ChatGPT, the legal team at the Lento Law Firm can help. Get in touch today by calling 888-535-3686 or going online to contact us.